Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links. This means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
If you love The Nightmare Before Christmas, there’s a good chance Sally is one of your favorite characters.
Her stitched-together charm, patchwork dress, and hauntingly sweet vibe make her the ultimate inspiration for Halloween or cosplay makeup looks.
Whether you’re going for spooky glam or screen-accurate Sally makeup, these 14 Sally Nightmare Before Christmas makeup ideas will help you bring the ragdoll beauty to life in your own unique way.
1. Sally Look
Start with the signature pale blue skin using face paint or cream makeup.
Draw the black stitches across your cheeks, forehead, and neck with eyeliner or body paint.
Finish the look with deep red lips and long lashes.
This is the most iconic Sally style and perfect for purists who want to resemble the movie version.
2. Glamorous Sally Makeup
Add a touch of sparkle to Sally’s usual look by using shimmering blue eyeshadow, highlighter on the cheekbones, and glitter under the eyes.
Replace the matte blue skin with a glowy finish foundation. It’s Sally — but make her runway ready.
3. Half Sally, Half Human
For a more creative twist, do Sally makeup on one half of your face and a glam human look on the other.
This symbolizes the transformation between fantasy and reality.
It’s a perfect balance of creepy and beautiful — ideal for parties or makeup competitions.
4. Stitched Doll Sally
Enhance the stitched effect by using liquid latex to create raised “seams” on your skin.
Paint over them with black and silver lines to give a 3D effect.
This adds realism and makes your Sally look extra eerie up close.
5. Cartoon-Inspired Sally
Go for exaggerated, hand-drawn lines to mimic Tim Burton’s animation style.
Use bold black eyeliner to outline your eyes, nose, and lips, and contour with darker blues to give your face that sketch-like illusion.
This comic-style Sally pops beautifully in photos.
6. Soft Glam Sally
For those who prefer a more wearable Halloween makeup, keep the stitches subtle and the blue skin tone light.
Add rosy blush, natural lashes, and glossy lips.
You’ll still channel Sally’s spirit without going full-on costume mode.
7. Glitter Stitch Sally
Outline the stitches with silver or gold glitter liner instead of black.
This dazzling take makes the look more fun and festive, especially for themed parties.
Pair it with rhinestones around the eyes for a sparkling finish.
8. Dark Gothic Sally
Deepen the blue into a dusty gray and use dark purple eyeshadow with black lipstick.
This gives Sally a gothic, mysterious vibe — almost like a darker sequel version of her.
Perfect for moody Halloween lovers or gothic style fans.
9. Broken Doll Sally
Add cracked porcelain-like lines to your face using black and white eyeliner to mix the “broken doll” concept with Sally’s ragdoll aesthetic.
It gives a spooky yet beautiful appearance, ideal for Halloween photoshoots.
10. Pumpkin Queen Sally
Combine Sally’s look with Jack Skellington’s Halloween vibe.
Add orange and black tones to the eyeshadow and contour, then draw tiny pumpkins near the stitches.
This version celebrates both characters — a creative mashup fans will love.
11. Neon Sally
Replace the pastel blues with vibrant neon body paint that glows under UV light.
This futuristic take looks incredible for night events or glow parties.
Pair it with electric pink stitches and neon eyeliner to really stand out.
12. Realistic Sally
If you want to look like a live-action Sally, blend your blue tones with white foundation and contour with gray.
Add realistic shading around the eyes and use body paint to replicate her dress patterns on your shoulders.
The result is hauntingly lifelike.
13. Romantic Sally
Soften the entire look — light blue tones, delicate red lips, and fluttery lashes.
Instead of black stitches, use a deep brown for a less harsh effect.
This gives Sally a sweet, romantic feel, perfect for couples’ costumes with Jack.
14. Horror Movie Sally
Turn up the fear factor by using fake blood around the stitches and dark shadows around the eyes.
Smudge the makeup slightly to give a decaying effect.
This version of Sally looks like she just stepped out of a creepy stop-motion nightmare.
-
Use a good setting spray to keep your makeup in place all night.
-
A bright red wig and patchwork dress complete the transformation.
-
Always start with a moisturizer or primer before applying body paint to protect your skin.
With these 14 Sally Nightmare Before Christmas makeup ideas, you can bring your favorite ragdoll to life in your own unique way — from soft glam to horror chic.
Whether you’re heading to a Halloween party or doing a themed photoshoot, these ideas guarantee you’ll capture the eerie charm and heartwarming spirit of Sally.
